I have used Oriental Trading Company many times in the past for great goody bags but sometimes their selection of say, lip gloss, was limited.  Then I received a catalog from US Toy Company in the mail.  You should take a look if you have elementary aged kids having parties.  Tons of party supplies, play jewelry, tattoos, stickers, pencils, erasers, keychains, and bouncy balls!  Kid Heaven!  And just a little different selection from Oriental Trading Company to spice things up a bit!